Singing What Can’t Be Sung
My grandma died like 15 years ago but something stuck with me to this day. She was talking about the difference between my brother and I and said “Niel has a lovely singing voice! Matthew? Well…. Not so much”. She was right. I sound like an x-factor first round embarrassment or a 40 a day smoker crying into a microphone. When it comes to singing; I am the Walrus.
The fact that has stuck with me for so long either means I’m a giant man baby – totally possible – but I like to think of it as simply something I would wish I could be good at . Wouldn’t it be amazing to be a great singer? Wouldn’t it be amazing to have written a great song? Something that is permanent and brings others joy long past I’m thrown in some bushes and left to be eaten by wolves.
That desire to be great or to at least leave something great to the world is the essence of Yesterday.
Jack Malick (Himesh Patel) is a local singer who only manages to pull in crowds filled with his manager Ellie (Lily James), his four closest friends, a bunch of incomprehensible local drunks and volumes of empty space and disappointment.
All that changes when Jack gets hit by a bus and starts writing some of the greatest songs ever written. The twist is that in the moment when Jack’s face made sweet love to the front of the bus, the Beatles were erased out of existence except for in Jack’s memory. So starts a journey of fame and fortune off the back of other people’s greatness.
It’s a fun and novel concept and fits perfectly with the film’s quirky British indie comedy vibe. Small punctuations like “What are cigarettes?” continues the joke throughout the film without overstaying it’s welcome and stops it from being there only to serve the purpose of the plot.
At first I thought that this film was trying to angle Patel as a mark 2 version Karen Soni ( the taxi driver in Deadpool) but thankfully not. In fact his race is never brought up except when suggesting his album is called The White Album.
It’s really nice that diversity in this film just… exists… the filmmakers just let it be. It makes a nice change to watch something, especially in the hellscape that is everyday life, to see something so focused on appreciation of an art form because for fuck sake diversity should just be normal.
Arguably the film tries to go too far with the scale of Malick’s success as I found myself losing conviction that the levels of success he achieved could happen so quickly and dramatically. A couple of wooden cameos from Ed Sheeran and not enough moral conflict over Malick’s plagiarism diminished the impact what seemed like the film’s main purpose.
We are left with is a story of friendship and a classic “will they, won’t they” dilemma between Jack and Elie. Patel and James have wonderful on screen chemistry that as sweetness and an innocence to it that should keep you invested until the end of the film so even though this is hardly a must see film, it is an enjoyable tale of love and some say that is all you need.
The Good, The Bad and The Outcome:
+ Fun concept
+ Diversity without any conditions
+
Main character’s chemistry
– The plot is bit rushed at points
– Doesn’t make the most of its concept
–
Ed Sheeran’s wooden cameo